Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2008/04/21
[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]Thanks, Marty. It's still a toss up. The better eye relief, and finder clarity, provided by the ZM are major tipping points. Slobodan On Apr 21, 2008, at 6:57 AM, Marty Deveney wrote: > > Slobodan, > > I used a borrowed one a fair bit over 5 days with the 35/2 and 50/2 > lenses. To compare, I have a 0.72 MP and a 0.85 M7 and used two > M6s as my main cameras for years. > > The Zeiss has a better viewfinder. It is larger, brighter, more > neutrally coloured and has longer eye relief. It does one weird > thing (if you're used to Leicas) - when the framelines shift to > compensate for parallax, the RF patch stays put. The effective > baselength is slightly longer than a 0.85 M, but slightly shorter > than that of an M3. This helped me focus lenses that can be hard > to focus. It has 28/85, 35 and 50 mm framelines; I found that > having the 35 and 50 on their own really pleasant. I found the > inability to use my 75 Summilux on it really unpleasant (there are > no 75mm framelines). It has a 0.74x finder - I would like a 1:1 > version, but this one worked fine. With the top removed, you can > see that the rangefinder is not designed like the Leica or Cosina- > Voigtlander RFs. The patch never flared in use, a major plus for > me (my MP flares occasionally and the pre-MP upgrade 0.85 finder in > my M7 is a flare monster - why Leica didn't bring back the > parabolic RF mi! > rror is beyond me). It loads from the back (nice) but rewinds > from underneath (what the!? - this is almost as strange as Leica > sticking to that stuid bottom loading system all these years - it > is awkward at best). In general the camera handles well, but > several friends commented that they thought it seemed to work > better for people with larger hands. > > The Ikon is not built like an M, it's lighter, there is more > plastic used in the construction and it will probably eventually > wear out. This does not bother me, it may bother some. The finish > on the black models is at least as nice as the black paint on my > MP. The Ikon is lighter than a Leica, which I like. But it makes > it quite front heavy with a Noctilux mounted. > > The Zeiss ZM lenses are great - I prefer the 35/2 to either the pre- > asph Leica 35/2 IV or the 35/2 asph, but this is a matter of > preference alone. The pre-asph Leica 35/2 IV has better out of > focus rendition, particularly from f4-8 and the 35/2 asph is > sharper. But the Biogon is a superb lens that produces photos that > I liked better than photos I took with either of those Leica ones > (having said that I am currently using a Leica 35/1.4 asph). The > 50/2 is equivalent to the latest Summicron 50/2 but doesn't flare > like the samples I've had. It is visibly better in the outer > fields than the Hexanon 50/2 I am currently using as my main lens > on my MP. > > Whether these are 'really' Zeiss lenses and cameras or not does not > bother me. It does bother some. The lenses seem to be better > coated than the C-V lenses, they felt extremely well put together > to me (as good as modern Leica stuff, still a way off the rock > solid heft and smoothness of the Leitz-era rigid Summicrons, > Contarex lenses etc - you know, the very, absolutely best - though > I often wonder if we use best where we probably should say most - > constructed stuff) and performed extremely well. I have always > thought that the T* coatings made a difference and this seems to be > the case with these lenses too. I didn't like the little 'bump' > that you are supposed to use to focus. The camera is as well made > as some of the Kyocera built SLRs, of which I was very fond, but > some of them seemed only so-so too. > > Well worth a look, but might be an acquired taste - try before you > buy, but I liked it. > > Marty > > Gallery: > http://gallery.leica-users.org/main.php?g2_itemId=7617 > > Most people can only judge of things by the experiences of ordinary > life, but phenomena outside the scope of this are really quite > numerous. > Shen Kuo - 'Dream Pool Essays' > > > -- > Want an e-mail address like mine? > Get a free e-mail account today at www.mail.com! > > > > _______________________________________________ > Leica Users Group. > See http://leica-users.org/mailman/listinfo/lug for more information