Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2010/10/24

[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]

Subject: [Leica] Nikon or Canon Full Frame; All Good (Older User's Perspective)
From: s.dimitrov at charter.net (slobodan Dimitrov)
Date: Sun, 24 Oct 2010 14:38:42 -0700
References: <11359F3F-0988-4897-AA91-F8BF81ADE0C4@comcast.net> <7FDD9A84-EB1A-4518-89AB-F55957171AB7@charter.net> <1C5C3CAA-6F2B-4C72-AED0-A5C2569A6586@comcast.net> <B3BA68A3-D55B-434A-B23A-8BDA8EA6D618@charter.net> <A5846CE6-5B27-450A-AC1C-4BDAA8C31214@comcast.net>

Congrats, Bob!
I tried using Leica glass with manual focus on DSLR. It's a waste of  
time, and time I don't have in one-time-only situations.
If I hadn't been into Canon glass at the beginning, I would of opted  
for a Nikon.
In that earlier time, the Canon, being plastic, was a light back-up  
for chromes, while shooting with a Rollei.
I just cant seem to get the missus to let me spring for more L glass!!!
S.d.


On Oct 24, 2010, at 1:37 PM, Bob Shaw wrote:

> I was drawn to the D700 based on multiple Leitax posts and from  
> other internet sources.
>
> I went to Glaser's Camera in Seattle (Leica dealer) and negotiated -  
> as in I didn't get stabbed too deeply - and traded of my entire R  
> Kit:  R8, R9, 28-90 Asph, 70-180 APO, Motor Drive and Charger for  
> what I thought was going to be a D700 with two zooms of similar  
> range (if not quality).
>
> I ended up with a 5D Mk II, 24-105 USM, 70-200 USM MkII and a 430 Mk  
> II flash, primarily because the comparable Nikon kit was nearly  
> $900.00 more for Nikon.  Because I promised myself whatever I  
> "bought" would have to be a net zero transaction.  Nothing personal;  
> just business.
>
> Now in my opinion either camera is a major improvement just for the  
> ease of shooting.
>
> So, why all of a sudden this change?
>
> 1.  After roughly 300 exposures, I see that I am now getting back  
> what I saw through the view finder, not what the CD yields after  
> scanning Leica R negs.  Dynamic Range to Burn.
>
> 2.  Almost all my shots are in focus.  If they're not, it's still my  
> fault for not believing what the little red rectangles were trying  
> to tell me.
>
> 3.  The full-frame sensor produces tons of dynamic range and very  
> rewarding enlargements.  Of course, same with D700.
>
> 4.  No more tiresome whining about poor shots to my patient, long- 
> suffering wife.
>
> 5.  I really grew tired of waiting for an R10 to hook up with my  
> legacy Leica glass.
>
> 6. Oh yeah, and I'm not getting any younger (indirect quote from Dr.  
> Ted).
>
> So my only film camera now is the trusty Contax T2 which is in rehab  
> while I look for a replacement back door - the Kyocera Ceramic film  
> pressure plate developed a hairline crack, rendering all exposures  
> just slightly out of focus.  My wife can't wait for it to get well -  
> she loves the camera and what it yields.  But it's a keeper.
>
> To be sure, the Canon(Nikon) lenses are no match for the heft,  
> haptics and results of Leica glass, but I've also been a bit amazed  
> at the results from the new 70-200, especially hand held.  Come to  
> think of it, the new 24-70 makes a great "on-camera" lens when I use  
> it properly.
>
> This isn't about D700 vs 5D Mk II.  It's about the freedom for an  
> older guy with a less steady hand and focusing eye to harvest images  
> worthy of keeping in iPhoto for later "migration" to Aperture for  
> serious fine tuning.
>
> This change has been so easy I almost felt guilty.  But I don't.
>
> I'm enjoying photography again and will continue to contribute to  
> the LUG as long I can be helpful and learn from such a fine  
> collection of ladies and gentleman photographers.
>
>
> Cheers,   Bob in Seattle
>
>
> Bob Shaw
> rsphotoimages at comcast.net
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Leica Users Group.
> See http://leica-users.org/mailman/listinfo/lug for more information



Replies: Reply from rsphotoimages at comcast.net (Bob Shaw) ([Leica] Nikon or Canon Full Frame; All Good (Older User's Perspective))
In reply to: Message from rsphotoimages at comcast.net (Bob Shaw) ([Leica] Nikon or Canon Full Frame; All Good (Older User's Perspective))