Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2000/01/10

[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]

Subject: [Leica] Is an M6 with 50mm the right tool for me?
From: Matt_Shimao@3com.com
Date: Mon, 10 Jan 2000 20:15:10 -0800

Hello,

I am considering the purchase of an M6 and a 50mm lens.  My current equipment is
fine, except for the weight and bulk.  I am looking to the M6 as a camera that I
can carry with me almost all the time.  One of my cameras is a 6x7 and I enjoy
using this camera for landscape photos.  I would use the M6 as my first-choice
camera for people photos.  I want to carry just the camera with one lens
attached.  Quickly, I eliminated the 75mm and 90mm lenses, as these are too long
to make for a truly portable package.  Why a 50mm instead of a 35mm?  I'll be
able to use the 50mm for head-and-shoulders portraits; the 35mm is too wide for
this purpose.

I do think the M6 will do a great job.  Really, I suppose I am looking for more
information about the 50mm Summilux and Summicron lenses (the current ones as
well as the previous versions).  I have dutifully searched the archives and have
learned that the current versions of both are very sharp.  However, I'm really
not that concerned about sharpness.  I am more interested in the elusive
qualities of bokeh.  On another mailing list, a prominent member recently wrote
that most 50mm lenses have poor bokeh.  In the archives, there is much mention
of the good bokeh of the pre-asph 35mm Summicron.  Regarding the bokeh of the
50mm lenses, there are not many posts--I've read that the current Summilux is
good, the current Summicron is not as good as the previous version, and that the
current Summicron is not very good because of the new design which has more flat
surfaces.  However, because my search turned up just a few posts, I don't feel
that there is a strong consensus, and so I am looking for more user opinions.

I understand that the qualities of bokeh are hard to quantify.  However, if
there are any users of the 50mm Summilux or Summicron who have opinions on this
topic, I would be grateful to hear them.

Originally in writing this, I titled this post, "50mm M lenses".  However, I
changed the title because I think maybe my motive here is to convince myself to
buy an M6.  That is why the bokeh question is really important to me--if one of
the 50mm has great bokeh, that would justify the cost for me.  Otherwise, much
less-expensive alternatives will probably meet my needs equally well.

Thank you,

Matt